Mean Reversion Machine

Mean Reversion Machine – GW11: Jackson-shaped hole

A regular excuse to use fantasy football as a metaphor for portfolio management

Equity markets may have been going bananas of late but, here in the realm of fantasy football – and even by the standards of the newly elongated international breaks – it has been awfully quiet. There was a time when mere boredom in the face of an FPL-free fortnight was at least enough to provoke meaningful ownership swings and price changes but apparently even that is no longer the case.

For whatever reason – be it managers keeping their powder dry and building up free transfers ahead of the busy Christmas period or, just possibly, having more interesting things to do with their lives than me – this has been a deeply dull time to be the adviser on the Mean Reversion Machine, with the only suspense available lingering around the fitness of Chelsea striker Joao Pedro.

And in the spirit of maintaining that suspense a little longer … at the excellent Fantasy Football Scout, you can find this fine piece around the benefits of patience from Simon March – a former FPL champion and, judging by the way he writes, someone not wholly unfamiliar with financial markets. “Now that we can go a whole five Gameweeks without using or losing a transfer, the option to be more patient is more viable,” he observes.

“It has exposed something we probably did not pay much attention to before, which is even the best players tend to blank quite a lot of the time.” Over the 2025/26 season, for example, the seven highest-scoring midfielders or forwards in the game blanked, on average, almost two-fifths of the time. Even Erling Haaland and Bruno Fernandes, last term’s two stand-out performers, respectively blanked in 37% and 29% of their matches.

“What this reveals,” March argues, “is that exercising patience with certain blanking players may well be a better strategy than constantly shifting between them. If so, a consequence, intended or otherwise, of banking transfers is it gives ‘regression toward the mean’ a chance to work in these managers’ favour. This could also help to negate any opportunity cost incurred from not making transfers for a prolonged period.”

Top mean-regression-based food for thought for the more actively-inclined manager – although, back in tracker territory, we are granted no such freedom (or opportunity to make any such emotional type of error). And so, with Joao Pedro confirmed as still off-games, Aston Villa’s Nicholas Jackson, the most-bought player ahead of Gameweek 11, duly becomes the Mean Reversion Machine’s newest asset. The portfolio thus looks like this:

“The market continues to display a worryingly high level of discernment – and where is the fun in that?

Source: Fantasy Premier League

Source: Fantasy Premier League

As for our latest numbers, after an inappropriately good start to the season, performance has duly settled down to a more acceptable average and that continued into Gameweek 10. As you can see below, our Arsenal trio of Calafiori, Gabriel and Raya, highly-owned Brighton pair De Cuyper and Gross and ‘part-time’ Manchester City midfielder Cherki were all successes. Most notably, our misfiring perma-captain Haaland was not.

Finishing as always with our ‘Herdwatch’ round-up of the most bought and sold assets in the game, the market continues to display a worryingly high level of discernment – and where is the fun in that? Among the leading buys in the top-left table below, only the appearance of cut-price Everton striker Barry in fourth place – after finally remembering where the goal is against Coventry last time out – might be described as knee-jerk.

On the ‘sells’ side, meanwhile, only the ongoing fire-sale of Manchester United midfielder Mbeumo feels a little ill-judged – surely if you still own him you wait to see if new manager Mauricio Pochetino can get a tune out of the team’s expensive array of attacking talent? Yes, the 4-4 draw with Villa was a spectacular piece of points-dodging by Mbeumo but the result underlines what the team can do when it does feel in the mood.

Given the embarrassment of riches suddenly available to FPL managers in the striker department, the continued abandonment of Leeds centre-forward Calvert-Lewin is more understandable even if, as I noted last time, he is now heading into an enticing run of fixtures. As such, despite his plummeting ownership, I find myself prioritising other transfers – and, while there is usually some solidly objective rationale for doing so, I am well aware that shows this project still has room for emotion and thus for human error.

Source: Fantasy Premier League

Source: Fantasy Premier League